Interview with Michael Cataliotti

Hello Mr.Michael Cataliotti! Thank you for returning for a second interview today. We deeply value your willingness to share your insights with us again. My pleasure! Always happy to chop it up and get some quality information out there. Today, we aim to provide insight into the current U.S. immigration situation and its practices, shedding light on the legal complexities and the substantial rewards of working in the United States.

Q: You specialize in a rather niche area of immigration law, assisting tattoo artists from outside the U.S. in obtaining work visas. What sparked this focus?
A: I do, but I also help a lot of other artists, entertainers, athletes, entrepreneurs, and workers across industries. When I started my practice, I had already been working in law for 6 years or so, in different areas and across different industries; I knew how I wanted to practice and what I wanted to focus on: Corporate, Entertainment, and Immigration. I also knew that in more traditional areas-like music, fashion, and film-there were a ton of people focused on those individuals and entities. I wanted to help and support lesser known, lesser recognized, and lesser respected disciplines and industries. Tattooing was one such area, as was burlesque, avant-garde jazz, animal training, adult film and entertainment, and a whole host of others. Everyone deserves help and support, not just those who are more traditionally focused. Those cases aren't as easy, necessarily, but they take more creativity, flexibility, and craftiness to be able to properly present a persuasive argument and understand the nuances.

Q: What are the primary types of work visas that international tattoo artists typically qualify for?
A: It's interesting: People always assume the only visa they can get is an O-1 or they lean on the EB-1 (green card) pathway. And yes, the O-1 is the most common, the one that most folks have and that makes the most sense for most artists. There are others, though, such as an L-1, if, for instance, an artist owns a studio outside of the U.S. and wants to open a branch or another within the U.S. An E visa may be applicable for someone from certain countries who wants to invest in and open their own studio or brand in the U.S. It could also work for individual artists who are going to work within that studio in the U.S. from that country.

Q: What are some of the biggest challenges these artists face when trying to immigrate to the U.S. for work?
A: I often find folks struggling to figure out where to work, with whom to work, and how to structure their visas. Everyone is different, and some folks like to move around, not be committed to any one particular place, whereas others enjoy and appreciate the comradery and comforts that come with being part of a group. I don’t believe there’s any right or wrong way to go about this, but it does seem to come up regularly with folks. And to be clear, I’m not speaking strictly about tattoo artists: Remember, I represent a wide range of individuals from visual artists who are sculptors and painters, to live performance, dancers, singers, actors, playwrights, opera singers and librettists, among many, many more. For some, it’s easy: They’re coming here to work with one institution, organization, establishment, studio, and that’s it, done, easy. For others who have that desire to bounce around, it can be more complicated. Now, that’s in terms of the preparation for the filing and the like. On the other side of things, is the governmental processes and procedures. Those can be incredibly haphazard and all over the place. Most notably, there has been significant pushback at the Embassies and Consulates worldwide, with Consular Officers seemingly looking for reasons to refuse visa applications.

Q: Can you walk us through the typical process for a tattoo artist seeking an O-1B visa?
A: So, it always begins with evaluating someone’s credentials to determine the types of documentation they have. Like most things, you can qualify, have the best name in the business, but if you can’t prove it, well, it won’t work. For me, once we start the process of preparing the petition, I begin by drafting the letters of recommendation, based on the materials provided to me. Those letters are for individuals who have agreed to support the artist in the process. We draft the framework, but leave it to the person signing and/or the artist to modify and adjust however appropriate. Once those are signed, we move on to the memo that details the person’s qualifications, and compiling the evidence to support those qualifications for example, if I’m saying that someone has 7 awards from 5 conventions, I need to demonstrate that the conventions are reputable or prominent, and that the awards, too, are reputable and prominent or competitive. Once this is all done, we then send it to the client to review. If acceptable, great, on it goes to a colleague of mine who I ask to review and issue a consultation opinion if he deems their qualifications acceptable. If so, then great, I get that letter, it goes into the file, and out the door it goes to USCIS. (I’m stripping this down to the most barebones process here, but it’s the basics.) After filing, USCIS will either approve outright, or ask for more information / clarity (a “request for evidence” or “RFE”). RFEs are not unusual and increasingly common (again, as they were during the first Administration). An RFE can be administrative-asking for clarifications about the work relationship or duties-or comprehensive-asking about every detail and aspect of the person’s background. Responding depends on strategy and the content of the request. Once you respond to the RFE, USCIS will then issue its decision of either approving, or denying the petition. And there you go. If they deny, for whatever reason, usually, you’ll want to refile, unless something is glaringly wrong in the decision (not just a subjective opinion by USCIS), in which case, you may want to file a motion or an appeal. In either of those situations, though, the wait time can be anywhere from 3 months to 14 months. You’re usually better off just refiling.

Q: What advice would you give to a tattoo artist living abroad who dreams of working in the United States?
A: Do not wait until you feel you have all of your paperwork ready, or a perfect case (presumably to guarantee approval): you’ll never be fully ready and there is no such thing as a guaranteed approval in immigration, especially U.S. immigration. Regardless of what you hear and what people say, no outcome is guaranteed and anyone who says otherwise is full of it. That aside, though, if you are going to go through this process with an attorney, be sure you’re comfortable with whomever you choose. You must have mutual respect, confidence, trust, and comfort with the person representing you. If you don’t, or if you just don’t gel with that person, that’s fine, go elsewhere. I don’t try to tell everyone I’m for them-I’m not! I don’t bullshit and I don’t have time to sugarcoat things for people. That can come across as inconsiderate, but my job isn’t to be considerate, it’s to strategize how to best realize your goals, whatever they may be. It’s important, though, to focus on these aspects: (1) Start early, and (2) Choose the best attorney for you.

Q: Moving on to broader immigration issues, we are currently in the second term of a Trump administration. What are some of the key immigration policies and trends you've observed under this administration that might impact international artists seeking to work in the U.S?
A: The same nonsense and pushback that they did during the first Trump Administration, they’re doing again, but ramped up: blanket, redundant, or nonsensical requests for evidence (RFEs), that delay the process; increased denials (for certain industries and categories, though I’m not experiencing that too much within the tattoo arts and body modification space); and this is where the newest aspect comes in - refusals of visas at the Embassies and Consulates. So, after someone files their petition for a classification, let’s say the O-1with USCIS, and it gets approved, if that person was in the U.S. at the time of filing and approval, at some point, whenever that person leaves the U.S, before returning, they will need to apply for a visa stamp at a U.S. Embassy or Consulate outside of the U.S. The same goes for someone who was never in the U.S. at the time of filing or approval. Historically, the majority of folks would be able to breeze through these, as purely administrative or ministerial matters. Now, not so much: Consular Officers are diving deep into social media posts, twisting notions of what is or is not “work” within the United States, and seemingly looking for reasons to refuse someone’s visa application. To put it bluntly: It’s bullshit. But, knowing this, we can better prepare and plan both for the interview, as well as a potential refusal (such as reapplying, utilizing a Congressional representative to weigh in, applying for a waiver if needed, possibly suing).

Q: Have there been any specific policy changes or executive orders under this second Trump administration that directly affect O-1B visas or the arts and entertainment industries?
A: They haven’t gone after O-1s directly, but absolutely there are policies and practices that impact arts and entertainment industries. Look at the recent Proclamations that effectively bar folks from entering the U.S. at all, or in certain categories, such as B, F, M, or J visas: plenty of folks come here to study, train, perfect their crafts (whether it be acting, painting, performing, singing, writing), or competing in competitions, which is generally lawful under a B visa and ESTA. Now, some of those restrictions have modifications to them, such as, validly issued visa holders will not be barred from entering the U.S, even if from a country listed in the Proclamation, but, realistically, who knows how that will play out at the Border?

Q: What are some of the most pressing immigration issues that you believe need to be addressed in the U.S. today?
A: I have to start with the actions by ICE, which have turned into a roaming gang, wrangling anyone who seems to be in their way. Policies and practices within Immigration should be nuanced, surgical, you don’t go fishing with a net: you always catch things you didn’t intend, don’t need, and don’t want. Unfortunately, this Administration is fishing with a net and not caring one bit about who they catch. No one is saying don’t go and arrest the individuals harming or threatening our neighborhoods; people are saying, be careful and focus your energies and attention on those people, not the barber who’s mean with the tape-up, or the woman who’s fierce with the tailoring, or the parents who work a combined 3 or 4 jobs to let their kids have better lives. Another aspect is the absolutely horrendous practices by USCIS officers, and Consular Officers, to try and make it increasingly more difficult for folks to enter the U.S. This notion of “the good ones” is fake, it’s bullshit, it was never real, and was always a way to get people to try and favor one group or kind of person over another. Really, there are a lot. The entire system is a mess, and needs a proper overhaul to bring it current. We could have had that several times, but it was either blocked by one party, or the other was too afraid to take action and do anything about it, so, here we are.

Q: Given the current political climate, what is your outlook for international artists seeking to work in the U.S. in the coming years?
A: It’ll get better. These things won’t last. Remember, artists are big business, no matter how much this Administration and its supporters may not be aware or think otherwise. And it goes beyond artists: don’t forget that athletes also get the O visa and P visas. Plenty of those folks are from Mexico, Central and South America, as well as Africa, Eastern Europe, and South Asia (really, just plain worldwide). We’ve already started seeing this attitude shift with a recent post by Trump where he’s seemingly just learning that his policies and practices are hurting the agriculture/farmers, and hospitality/hotels and such, industries. Go figure.

Q: You mentioned the importance of a U.S. employer. What are some of the key considerations for a tattoo studio looking to sponsor an international artist?
A: This is key: I often advise studios, not just artists, about what they can or can’t, should or shouldn’t do. In terms of a studio, it’s the same idea as most in that you want to find a person who has the right fit for you, for your studio, your brand, your group of artists. You also have to know what you want your studio to look like and feel like: Do you want a select group of artists that will be committed to you and your brand, rotating as needed or desired, or do you want a mix of folks who are residents and guests. Totally up to you, and again, there’s no right or wrong, but you should be mindful of it. You also have to decide if you want to be the one to hold the artist’s visa as the sponsor, or if you’re fine being the employer only.

Q: Are there any ethical considerations that arise when representing international artists seeking work visas?
A: Always. There are various aspects here, that range from whether you’re engaging in dual representation-as in, representing the artist and the studio that’s sponsoring them to communications. Dual representation is an important aspect to be mindful of: For my part, with certain studios, I tell folks upfront and clearly that I represent both them, and the studio/sponsor, meaning if they have an opinion where they want to leave the l studio, or stop the process with the initially agreed upon studio/sponsor, and they tell me before the studio/sponsor, then the artist has 24 hours to notify the studio/sponsor or else I will. Likewise, it goes the other way, too: If the studio/sponsor tells me that they are no longer going to work with an artist, they have 24 hours to notify the artist or else I do. It keeps everyone honest and clear, clean, avoiding any confusion behind the scenes. This usually isn’t so much of an issue, though, it is something I point out to folks from time to time. The bigger issue, and the one that really gets me, is when I see or hear about these folks-whether they’re lawyers or not who are posting about their clients getting a visa or a green card or whatever else. If you’re an attorney, or an accredited representative, your job, your entire world, is to be behind the scenes, quiet, doing your job, to get your client(s) what they are after. You are not the center of attention; that’s the artist, studio, client(s). If the artist wants to go and post about their approval(s), so be it, that’s their decision; if the studio wants to post about it in one way or another, so be it, again, that’s their decision; but why would an attorney or representative do this? To help the artist? To promote the studio? It makes no sense. There is no value added for anyone to know that an individual obtained a visa, nor that a studio sponsored someone. If the argument is that it helps promote the artist and lets people know they’re going to be available for work in the U.S., you can do that without commenting on their immigration status. And, in case it needs to be said, this really isn’t the time that you want to promote someone as holding a visa or green card. Attorneys are supposed to speak when it benefits our clients, helps alleviate or clarify something for their benefit. I’ve worked in a variety of areas of law over the last 20 years, and I’ve yet to see any value to a client in an attorney posting things and commenting about someone’s immigration status. I can see the value to the attorney or the representative, though.

Q: What role do professional organizations or unions play in the immigration process for artists, particularly in providing advisory opinions for O-1B visas?
A: They are mandatory. Any and every O-1 petition must have either a consultation opinion from a labor organization, labor and management organizations, or a peer advisor if neither exists. What that means for folks in the tattoo and body modification areas, is that you’ll need or want an additional letter of recommendation, attesting to the artist’s qualifications and abilities. Now, this has to come from someone based within the U.S. The person does not have to be a U.S. citizen, but they must be qualified to comment on the individual, and they must be based in the U.S.

Q: Have you seen any shifts in the types of evidence that USCIS finds most persuasive when evaluating the extraordinary ability of tattoo artists?
A: Not shifts, really. It’s the same old item for most anyone: Press. It’s always been and always will be press. Think about it, though, it’s easy to identify the quality and content. Serving as a juror is also great, as are awards, but I often find that being a juror is a notch above, as you are the one who’s deemed to be so exceptional, that you qualify to judge the work of others. In the O-1A space, there’s a category just for this, but unfortunately there isn’t in the O-1B. Either way, it’s the usual materials: Press is paramount, followed by any other industry achievements (awards, honors, juror roles), and also look at your hourly or session rate, with the applicable split. If you’re the kind of artist who doesn’t go to conventions, well, that’s fine, maybe you have a significant number of Instagram followers. If you don’t, all right, well, maybe you just focus on your work, building your studio, and that’s it, so your studio is one of the pre-eminent ones. Perhaps you have all-star, or famous clientele. These are all angles and evidence that shape the narrative for an O-1.

Q: For tattoo artists who successfully obtain a work visa, what are some common pathways to permanent residency (a green card) in the U.S.?
A: There’s the EB-1A, which I think most people know about-it’s essentially the green-card version of the O-1, and with that, comes a very high standard of review, level of scrutiny, and need for recognition. Unlike the O, though, it doesn’t provide a status at the outset, unless you’re filing concurrently - submitting the EB-1A filing (same as the O-1 with all of the documentation and qualifications), as well as the green card filing (this is the more administrative aspect, but it is fully dependent on the success of the EB-1A, or else it fails). There’s also an EB-2 NIW that could work well, which is for individuals who have either an advanced degree or its equivalent, or “exceptional ability”, not to be confused with “extraordinary ability”. This would require similar showings to that of the O-1 and EB-1A, but it would also require showing that whatever the artist is going to do, is in the national interest, such that they should not need to have a job offer. Essentially, the person is going to contribute something so great to the U.S. that we don’t particularly care about determining if anyone else can do it. The EB-1A can be faster all around, whereas the EB-2 NIW is backlogged by about 2 years or so, between filing the first part and the actual application for a green card. It isn’t ideal for most folks.

Q: Given the potential for stricter enforcement and policy changes, many international artists express concerns about discrimination or the fear of potential deportation. How do you address these anxieties with your clients?
A: It’s real. And it’s a genuine concern that shouldn’t be dismissed. But, if you prepare folks for what to expect when entering the U.S., what to do if someone stops you, what to carry, what to say, and you stay available for them, it helps (I think, I’ve been told). I’m pretty available in most cases (hell, I’m responding to e-mails and texts from clients while I type this up at 11:04 pm on a Thursday).

Q: What specific legal challenges do you anticipate if the Trump administration implements stricter immigration enforcement, particularly concerning those with valid work visas?
A: I’ll be filing more lawsuits, I can tell you that. So long as clients don’t stop me, or at least cover some of the hourly costs, I’ll be filing a hell of a lot of suits to fight back. You’re already seeing the ACLU file a bunch, and win, State Attorneys General file a bunch, and win. So, the momentum is there, it just needs to not falter or waver. The hardest part is going to be suing over folks not getting their visas issued (at the Embassies or Consulates), because you really can’t sue for that. It’s generally deemed a matter of national security, making it incredibly difficult to fight against.

Q: How do you advise clients to prepare for potential changes in immigration law that could affect their status?
A: One step at a time. There are some things that we can foresee coming-like stricter and more in-depth reviews of social media, more requests for evidence, possibility of denials or refusals, or administrative processing at the Embassies/Consulates and those you can plan for, but most of it, you just have to roll. I thought I was so philosophical saying “just be like water”, until a handful of folks told me Bruce Lee said this some 40/50 years ago, so, I guess great minds think alike? :) It’s exactly what we need to do now, though: Be like water. You can slow water, divert it, stop it temporarily, but you can never truly beat it. And so, I try to let folks know that they aren’t alone, and as I have anything of value, I’ll let them know, and we can strategize how to move forward. If they hear of something, by all means, ping me, that’s what I’m here for, and I want to know.

Q: In your opinion, what are the ethical responsibilities of immigration lawyers in this potentially volatile climate?
A: To zealously represent their clients, don’t put them in a bad light or spot, maintain communication that is crucial these days (it always is, but even more so now) and fight the nonsense that we’re seeing. This is not the time to sit back, post on your social media, and play pretend; this is the real world, and this administration has made it clear that they don’t like Immigration lawyers; they don’t want us around or involved in these things.

Q: Beyond the legal hurdles, what are some crucial aspects of American culture and the tattoo industry that international artists should be aware of before relocating?
A: I think a lot of that depends on which part of the U.S. someone’s going to. For instance, NYC is going to have a completely different vibe from Long Island, which will be closer to, but still different from upstate New York. That’s just there. Now, Florida, Texas, Louisiana, California, Oregon and Washington, the Dakotas, Illinois, and so on, these are all going to have different vibes and attitudes. Find where you’re comfortable maybe you know already! Maybe you don’t, but find your space. Depending on where you were living before, or where you were raised during your formative years, maybe a more rural/country area is going to be better and more enjoyable. Maybe you know you need the water, or a tropical climate, so, there you go. Different cities, different States and towns, will have different attitudes in many cases, extremely different. In terms of the industry, I’ll leave that to the artists and studio owners/managers. :)

Q: How crucial is a strong building client base and networking?
A: As important as anything else. If you’re an artist, you’re a brand, even if you’re part of a bigger brand. Now, some studios will promote you, and do your bookings and all for you. That’s great. Not all do. So, be mindful of that.

Q: What are some common financial considerations that international tattoo artists might overlook when planning their move to the U.S?
A: You can make a lot of money here, but it’s also expensive in most of the places you’ll be doing that. So, be mindful. And when tax time comes, just prepare, be sure to have a good accountant who understands the laws and treaties in place between your home country and the U.S.

Q: How does the legal framework in the U.S. regarding intellectual property and artistic rights apply to tattoo artists, and what should international artists be aware of?
A: It’s funny, I wrote an article about this when I was in law school, it tied together tattoo ownership and also looked at graffiti/street art. I’ve always been interested in this area (and before I decided to focus fully on immigration, I used to do corporate and entertainment law, as well, so it was one of the focuses for me). I suppose it depends on the focus of the question, really. If you’re asking about who owns the artwork on the body, versus the photos of the artwork, versus the design, or anything else, well, that gets real messy. I’m not sure I can really answer this competently here, but hey, I’m happy to chat about it with folks if they have questions! I can also refer anyone to a crack attorney in this area.

Q: What are some common misunderstandings or misconceptions that international tattoo artists have about working in the U.S.?
A: That they can simply come in, make a ton of money, jump from one studio to the other with their visa in every situation, and the like. Folks also think that coming into the U.S. with a tourist visa or ESTA, and going to a convention and tattooing there constitutes work: It may, but it doesn’t necessarily have to. It depends on how the situation is structured and whether the artist is getting paid for the convention, or, if they are tattooing, and then collecting whatever they win. Because the latter, would generally be deemed to constitute participation in a competition, which is in most cases, acceptable.

Q: Considering your experience, what is the most rewarding aspect of helping international tattoo artists achieve their dream of working in the United States?
A: The entirety. I got into this area, because I wanted to be a musician, realized I didn’t have the support or internal drive to make it happen for myself, and I said, “Ok, well, I’m going to help other artists, the way I wasn’t.” I focused on corporate and entertainment law, as well as immigration, and after several years, decided to focus solely on immigration, because it’s more rewarding overall (for me). I make less than I did with corporate and entertainment, it’s more stressful, and more emotionally involved, this is the worst part for me... emotions aren’t my bag but man, when it works, being able to help someone make a jump or reach the next step in their life and career, that’s huge. It’s an honor and a privilege, truly. And look, even when it doesn’t work, and a case gets denied, or someone’s visa gets refused, the important thing is to know how to move forward, how to take the next step. That is when the attorney comes in to deliver, right? Not when it’s easy, but when it’s difficult. As much as I can’t stand the difficulties and in a perfect world, I wouldn’t even have a job doing this because it would all be streamlined, I love the fact that I can fight for my people and win.

Q: What message of encouragement would you offer to international tattoo artists who are currently navigating the often-challenging U.S. immigration system?
A: Stay up. Stay positive. Stay confident. You’ll get there, wherever it is you’re trying to go, just be sure to have the right support. It can be a friend, family member, partner, attorney, whomever, just make sure you have that support. Because now, especially, things are messy, and this isn’t the kind of system you want to navigate alone.

Q: Finally, what is one key takeaway you hope our audience will remember from this discussion about immigration for international tattoo artists?
A: Things are difficult, and they will continue to be difficult, maybe even more so over the next several months and years, but don’t give up, have support, have confidence, and you’ll get there. \m/ ((><)) \m/ (Showing my age there feel free to rip that out.)
Mr. Michael Cataliotti, thank you for your insightful perspectives and valuable information. My pleasure! I truly hope this was useful to people.

You can read our first interview with Mr.Michael Cataliotti on this link.
Mr.Michael Cataliotti is our official partner who works with many tattoo artists we interviewed and are now living and working in the USA. You can find more about our Visa Interviews on this link.